Dissolved Air Flotation Systems (DAFs) for Bakeries
Prepared by:
Roy E. Carawan
Extension Food Science Specialist
North Carolina State University
Edd G. Valentine
Research Scientist
Georgia Tech Research Institute
Published by: North Carolina Cooperative Extension Service Publication
Number: CD-43
Last Electronic Revision: March 1996 (JWM)
DAF systems are often suggested for pretreating wastewater - will a DAF
work for your bakery? Bakeries are facing increasingly stringent
restrictions on their wastewater discharges. To help reduce the concentration
of contarninants in their wastewater and to avoid sewer surcharges, some plant
managers have installed systems to pretreat the wastewater before it is
discharged to municipal sewers or other disposal outlets. Many other managers
are considering pretreatment to reduce surcharges or have been asked by their
publicly owned treatment works (POTW) to consider waste reduction. One way to
pretreat wastewater is with a dissolved air flotation system (DAE;), which can
remove insoluble materials such as fats, oils, and grease (Figure 1).
Figure 1. A dissolved air flotation
(DAF) system.
At present, there is only limited experience with using DAF systems for
bakeries. This publication describes the DAF system and its operation and shows
you how to decide if a DAF is the appropriate choice for your bakery.
How a DAF Works
A DAF is a gravity separation system that uses air bubbles in a wastewater
holding tank to help float insoluble materials to the surface so they can be
removed. Some materials that are heavier than water can also be removed if
chemical flocculents are used. The flocculents cause these materials to join
together in clusters that are lighter than water and therefore float.
Pollutants are concentrated in the material that accumulates on the surface,
called the float. Other names for the float include DAF float, skimmings, or
sludge. Note that soluble contaminants such as sugar are not usually removed
by the system, although they are occasionally trapped in the float along with
other particles.
Similarly, bakery wastewater often contains a large amount of settleable
solidsmaterials such as dough pieces, bits of fruit, nuts, raisins, and
product. These materials will settle because they are heavier than water. Thus,
a DAF tends to negate the settling of these materials. Most heavier materials
will settle if given enough time, but some will be trapped with the float.
Therefore, the nature of these materials must be considered in DAF designs for
bakeries.
Questions to Ask
These are some of the questions to ask when considering the implementation of a
DAF system:
- Could the solids you want to remove be eliminated by process change
inside the plant?
- Is screening being used to remove coarse solids (before DAF
appliction)
- What is the ratio of soluble (dissolved) materials to insoluble
material (suspended matter)?
- Would the insolubie materials be removed by a DAF?How long will th
wastewater need to be in the DAF for the separation to take place?
- Would the removal percentage be enhanced by a DAF? Wil it b
necessary to use flocculent chemicals?
- What wastewater standards must be met? How much more stringen will
they become and what other standards will be added in the future?
- How much does the flow vary
- Is a DAF the best altemative among the many treatment technologies
that are availabie?
- What means of disposal is available for the skimmings?
- What are the costs of purchase and operation of a DAF, including
the disposal of the skimmings?
System Components and Operation
The three major parts of a DAF system are:
- the tank (rectangular or circular)
- the float recovery and collection system
- the pressurization pump and tank.
Types of Systems
Two types of DAF systems are commonly used:
- Full-flow pressurization systems
- Recycle-flow pressurization systems.
Variations in the commercially available systems include features such as tank
design (compact systems utilize inclined plate packs) and skimmer design.
Selecting a System of the Proper Size
DAFs are designed on the basis of the peak flow rate expected unless the
concentration of insoluble solids exceeds 3,000 milligrams per liter (mg/l).
The flow usually ranges from about 1 to 6 gallons per minute per square foot of
surface area (GPM/ft2). The diagram in Figure 2 shows how a DAF operates.
Figure 2. Operation of a DAF
system.
- Raw wastewater (A) mixes wiht the recycle water after the pressure
release valve (P) and enters the DAF tank. The water is released into a
coagulation tube (B) in the center of the tank. The water exits the top of the
tube and the air bubbles carry the solids to the surface. Top skimmers (C) move
the skimmings to the discharge trough (E) where they are collected. Treated
water exits from the lower sections of the DAF through the riser tubes or shirt
(H). Heavy solids that do not float settle to the bottom where a bottom skimmer
(F) moves them to the discharge point (G) for removal.
- In the recycle loop, the clarified water is injected with air and pumped
into a pressurization tank (O) where the air goes into solution. A pressure
control valve (P) is used to maintain the desired pressure on the system. On
the downstream side of the pressure control valve the pressure is released and
the air comes out of the solution forrning microscopic bubbles.
Observed Performance
Many food processing plants, such as poultry and meat processors, use DAFs as
pretreatment systems. The experience of these plants may be useful for bakery
managers as they consider DAFs for pretreatment. However, wastewater
characteristics vary widely, depending on the products produced and the time of
day. Also, bakeries use considerably less water than large meat and poultry
plants. Several bakeries are currently using DAFs as pretreatment systems.
These systems often have removal efficiencies similar to those in Figure 3.
Note that these DAF removal efficiencies were obtained from a multiproduct
bakery. Bread bakeries have substantially less biochemical oxygen demand (BOD^)
and fats, oils, and grease (FOG) contents. Therefore, opportunities for a DAF
in bread plants would be more limited.
Figure 3. DAF removal for
multiproduct bakery.
DAF Chemical Use
Decisions about the use of chemical flocculents in DAFs are based on cost,
system efficiency, and the intended use of the DAF float. Chemicals commonly
used include the trivalent metallic salts of iron, such as FeCI2 or FeSO4 or
aluminum, such as AISO4. Concentrations of chemical flocculents used
normally range from 100 to 500 mg/l. (One mg/l in 1 million gallons per day is
8.34 pounds of material.) The pH of the wastewater must be adjusted to fall
between 4.5 and 5.5 for the ferric compounds or between 5.5 and 6.5 for the
aluminum compounds using an acid such as H2SO4 or a base such as NaOH. In many
applications, after the DAF, a pH control system utilizing a base such as NaOH
may need to be added to assure that the discharge pH is within the limits
specified by the POTW.
Organic and inorganic polymers (anionic or cationic) are often used to
enhance the DAF process. The most commonly used inorganic polymers are the
polyacrylamides.
Organic compounds such as carrageenan, chitosan, and lignosulfonic acid, or
their derivatives can also be used. When the float is to be fed to animals
intended for human consumption, only materials that have been approved by the
United States Food and Drug Administration (FDA) Office of Veterinary Medicine
should be used.
Disposal of the Float
The pollutants removed by the DAF system are concentrated in the float and must
be used or disposed of properly to avoid environmental damage. DAF float can be
disposed of by:
- Applying it to land (A permit i required.) For more
information on DAF float disposal on land, contact your county Cooperative
Extension Center for application rates and your state environmental agency for
permit requirements.
- Depositing it in a landfill (This practice is banned in some
states.) Regulations usually require that the material be bladeable (not
sloppy).
- Rendering it. (The moisture content and chemical used can be
concerns.) Renderers usually request that the solids be in the 20-30 percent
range.
- Feeding it to animals. The chemicals should be approved by
the FDA, and the float often contains too much liquid for most feeding
applications.)
DAF Float Dewatering Systems
Because the DAF float often contains only 2 to l0 percent solids, it must often
be dewatered before utilization or disposal. The float is commonly dewatered
using one of the following methods:
- A belt filter press that uses poylmer
- A thermally enhanced sytem
- A centriuge
- A vacuum precoat filter using diatomaceous earth
- A filter press
- Decanting
Making Your Decision
In-plant changes that reduce wastes are the best and most economical way to
reduce pollution and should always precede treatment considerations. Bakery
managers need to carefully evaluate any decision to pretreat their wastewater.
A DAF is only one of a number of available wastewater treatment technologies.
Limited evidence is available to show that DAFs will work for bakeries.
Consider the pros and cons listed above. If a DAF is the best alternative, keep
in mind that most POTWs (and some states) require engineers to design
pretreatment systems. These systems must be designed to meet the effluent
limitations. Remember that the pollutants removed and concentrated by a DAF
must still be disposed of properly if pollution is to be avoided.
Dissolved Air Flotation Systems (DAFs)
PROS
- Reduce grease (FOGs)
- Reduce suspended solids (TSS) and settleable solids (but only if
equipped with a bottom sweep).
- May help bakeries meet POTW permit restrictions
- Do not require excessive maintenance or management
- May reduce surcharges, especially for larger bakeries CONS
- Do not remove soluble materials such as sugars
- Do not remove the BODs associated with soluble materials
- Only concentrate the pollutants; the float must still be disposed
of properly.
- Are costly to buy and are expensive to operate. (If high chemical
use is required, operational costs will be high.)
- They rarely cost less than surcharges, especially for smaller
bakeries.
Distributed in furtherance of the Acts of Congress of May 8 and June 30, 1914.
Employment and program opportunities are offered to all people regardless of
race, color, national origin, sex, age, or disability. North Carolina State
University, North Carolina A&T State University, U.S. Department of
Agriculture, and local governments cooperating.
CD-43